The Ties That Bind: Welcome to ‘Hey, Little Sister’

by paige on November 24, 2008

NEARLY FOUR YEARS AGO, I went to the hospital, on the day before my own birthday, and delivered a baby sister. She was just under 8 pounds, with a thick head of dark hair and deep, dark blue eyes that seemed to focus instantly, and would not let go. My husband likes to joke that if we’d had a daughter first, we might have thought our son a little, um, slow. He also occasionally says that if she’d been our first, she might have been our last. In both cases, though rude, he’s not necessarily wrong.

Her name means “Rock.” As in stone, not music. She lives up to it. At 3-1/2, she can carry on a conversation about almost any topic, whether she actually knows anything about it, or not. (In this, I am not too proud to say, she closely resembles her mother.) She has complicated relationships with an extended family of dolls, most of whom are named “Baby,” though a couple are called “Butterfly.” She can draw excellent flowers, recognizable humans, and vibrant suns.

She is absolute in her convictions, certain in her rectitude, on all subjects.

She terrorizes her 7-year-old brother.   Shrinks (at least the Jungians) will tell you that naming is everything, it is an act of power and creation.  I think that’s a lot of pressure to put on new parents, but I do notice that Seven, too, rises to meet his name, which means “river.”  He’s easy, for the most part: emotional, full of feeling, but also mellow. As a toddler, he was the kid who never (well, almost never) hit, bit or terrorized, and looked at those who did with gentle non-comprehension.  All of this, it should be said, changed when he met the Rock.

Until the last year or so, it was mostly sunshine and light between the sister and the brother. He openly doted on her, and she looked up to him, or ignored him, depending upon her mood. Both seem satisfied with this arrangement. When she started school, everything changed.

At first, they loved being in school together. (And they both complained bitterly this fall, when my son decamped to a different school.) But at home, things grew tense. He’d growl and grimace at her when she invaded his space. In response, she’d scream and cry and advance further into enemy territory, all at the same time.

Is this just the way it goes for siblings, and the scars from all these battles and counterattacks will be only that–healed reminders of old conflicts among allies?

Saying “no” to her just made her grit her teeth, elevate her decibel level and push harder for whatever it was she felt was her due. He’d respond in kind, calling out for parental reinforcements, or, instead, mounting his own assault, usually by grabbing and then letting go of her arm–this, after all, is a kid who doesn’t really believe in physical violence of the non-cartoon kind. Except when the target is the most annoying person in the world.

Then, my loving, sweet boy morphs into a ninja bad guy bent on revenge and destruction. Meanwhile, the instigator weeps and cries and my heart melts–she’s younger! she’s still a baby!–I know she’s a pain in the a** but don’t yell/grab/scare her!

“You always take her side,” he cries, wounded, slamming his bedroom door against both of us girls. And the thing is–I don’t–always take her side, that is. Really, when I’m rational, I see why she’s irritating, and understand why he responds, in anger, as he does. (I would, too, I suspect.) But at what point will she have to take responsibility for her behavior to him (or to the rest of us, for that matter?)

Or is this just the way it goes for siblings, and the scars from all these battles and counterattacks will be only that–healed reminders of old conflicts among allies?

You see–I don’t know. I don’t have any idea what a sister feels, or should feel, or what it is to be the youngest who’s never been alone or the oldest who remembers the luxury of solitude. I’ve only ever been an only. How in the world am I supposed to help these two navigate the high trails and falling water of siblinghood?

No related posts.

{ 14 comments… read them below or add one }

marionroach November 25, 2008 at 10:11 am

Always ask the sisters in your life for parenting advice – that’s my advice. You don’t have to take it, of course. But ask.

Chris November 25, 2008 at 10:07 pm

I am lucky enough to have a brother AND a sister, and a daughter and a son, and I have no better idea what to tell my children about how to be a sibling. But I suppose I will think about it more now that I have read this beautiful piece.

anastasia November 26, 2008 at 5:53 am

hooray for little sisters.

Kari November 26, 2008 at 11:46 am

Amazing Paige. I’m lucky to have you in my life. My relationship with my own sister tends to be unbalanced at best. And even still we’re just fine. Or fine enough.

Kari November 26, 2008 at 11:47 am

P.S. Baby Rock was adorable! She looks so different now – still completely adorable though.

Dan Shaw November 26, 2008 at 9:11 pm

I have a sister three years younger and I have adored her always–except when she annoyed me so much that I slammed doors and threw tantrums and wanted to hurt her. She was always brainier, funnier and more popular than I was, and I was always proud of her. And now when we reminisce about growing up and laugh till we cry, it is always our parents ridiculous behavior that is the source of our laughter. I can only laugh like that with my sister. She is the only other person on the planet who understands.

Paige November 26, 2008 at 10:52 pm

Aw, Dan–it is so sweet to hear you talk (or write) about your sister. I just hope my two can tell the same tales someday (absent, of course, the part about laughing about me!) Welcome to the Sister Project, and congrats on being the first male to comment!

hilary November 30, 2008 at 6:15 pm

dearest paige,

what a lovely lovely essay on sisterhood and learning to teach your kids to be sibs. i miss you over on your blog but so excited about your new project! congratulations!

xxxoooo

hilary

Rebecca December 3, 2008 at 5:55 pm

Mine are going through the same thing now — all I can do is to try to consume the pages of SIBLINGS WITHOUT RIVALRY as fast as I possibly can…

jessica December 3, 2008 at 6:03 pm

Being an only child myself and the mother of five,the last two being sisters, I look forward to hearing words of wisdom.I am amazed each day as to how they all get along with each other(or not)and who connects with who.The Sister project could not have come at a better time.Congratulations!

Pat Maloy December 3, 2008 at 7:17 pm

Thanks for getting in touch. I printed all 6 pages so I can show your picture to your Grandmother. She will be pleased to see it I am sure! You do look like your mother. An interesting subject to see your opinion on too. Love and Thanks, Aunt Pat

orloff December 3, 2008 at 8:46 pm

Wow, welcome Hilary, Rebecca, Jessica and (Aunt :-) ) Pat! Hilary, I want you chiming in here, because I know you’ve got a lot to say on this subject; Rebecca, I’m off to the bookstore for that book; Jessica, I’m in awe of anybody with more than two kids, and can’t wait to hear about the relationship that develops between your littlest ones, and Aunt Pat–I’m so glad you came by. I hope you’ll keep adding to the discussion, and definitely send my cousins, too!

Lee Rose Emery December 4, 2008 at 2:55 am

My dearest Paige, LONG LOST SISTER/FRIEND THAT YOU ARE – yes, you owe me a call or four.. But I see that you have been busy and am so proud of you. Love the site. I also always love your writing.
I gotta say I am really glad that 7 is annoyed by 3. For the longest time I marveled that he seemed to have no animosity towards her. My eldest was always clear, from the start…and she (2.5 years older than her brother) even uttered those cliche words that older siblings do, two days after he arrived home from the hospital. She was back from an outing at the park she climbed the steps to the house only to ask, “IS HE STILL HERE?” And that is pretty much what she laments daily: his existence in her life.
She too feels I always take his side, and it is awful because I do! See, I was the little sister. And my sister, although we are incredibly close now, tormented me as big sisters do. So I feel his pain. It is quite unfair.

There are moments of love between my children, a sweet impulse for an incomprehensible drawing given to one from the other, or a spontaneous kiss. Those moments mean so much because of all the rest. It’s all there in the same instant, I love you! I hate you! ARE YOU STILL HERE? But that is the ultimate gift of a sister or brother. No matter what, they are always still there. xo miss you, call me.

orloff December 4, 2008 at 7:00 am

Lee, you’re right–between your comment and another one I got this morning on my blog, clearly it’s (way past) time for a discussion of how to keep your sisters (of any kind) close, even when they’re not. I stink at keeping in touch–you’re the best at it. How do you manage?? And about that sibling rivalry thing–I wonder how it would have gone with mine if the Rock had come first. I think we might have exactly the same drama playing out at our house as you sometimes do at yours!

Leave a Comment